Black Gloves Found Near Nancy Guthrie Home, and Mystery Man Seen with TWO Backpacks, with Phil Holloway and More | Ep. 1251 - The Megyn Kelly Show Recap
Podcast: The Megyn Kelly Show
Published: 2026-02-12
Duration: 1 hr 45 min
Guests: Phil Holloway, Jim Fitzgerald, Maureen O'Connell, Will Geddes, James Hamilton
Summary
The episode dives into the Nancy Guthrie abduction case, focusing on new evidence such as gloves found near her home and video footage of a man with two backpacks. Experts discuss the potential implications for the investigation and the mystery surrounding a possible ransom demand.
What Happened
Phil Holloway reports live from Tucson, detailing the latest developments in the Nancy Guthrie abduction case. A key discovery includes a pair of black gloves found near her home, initially reported as one glove. These gloves are a focal point for forensic analysis, with the hope that DNA evidence could lead to the suspect's identification.
New video footage has emerged showing a man with two backpacks, dubbed 'Pac-Man,' seen five miles from Guthrie's home on the night of her disappearance. This individual, wearing a gray jacket and blue pants, was caught on camera trying to open a gate, raising questions about his involvement.
The timeline of events is under scrutiny, especially with discrepancies surrounding Nest camera footage timestamps. The doorbell camera went offline at 1:47 a.m., and the Nest cameras reportedly disconnected at 2:12 a.m., shortly before an image was detected, possibly of an animal.
The investigation is further complicated by reports of forced entry through the back door of Guthrie's home, which was left open. The FBI's search efforts include looking for a cell phone possibly linked to the suspect, a crucial piece of evidence that could accelerate the investigation.
Former FBI agents Jim Fitzgerald and Maureen O'Connell analyze the potential significance of a cheap backpack and low-quality gun holster found at the scene. They discuss how these items might provide leads, considering the suspect's apparent lack of sophistication.
The episode also examines the Bitcoin ransom demand reported by TMZ, which claims knowledge of the kidnapper's identity. Experts express skepticism about the demand's legitimacy, suspecting it could be a hoax or misdirection.
Law enforcement remains optimistic about Guthrie's survival, as her pacemaker synced with her phone until 2:28 a.m. on the night she vanished. The case's complexity is heightened by ongoing interviews with neighbors and the exploration of family dynamics, suggesting deeper motivations behind the abduction.
Key Insights
- A pair of black gloves found near Nancy Guthrie's home might crack the case. They were initially reported as just one glove, but now these gloves could hold the DNA to unmask a suspect, turning a simple discovery into a potential breakthrough.
- There's a mysterious 'Pac-Man' seen with two backpacks near Guthrie's home the night she vanished. Caught on camera trying to open a gate, his gray jacket and blue pants might just be the breadcrumbs leading to unraveling this abduction puzzle.
- Ever heard of a doorbell camera going offline at 1:47 a.m., then Nest cameras at 2:12 a.m., only for a possible animal image to appear? This timeline tangle raises eyebrows, suggesting a tech-savvy suspect or just some eerie coincidence.
- A Bitcoin ransom demand claiming to know Guthrie's kidnapper. Experts think it's a potential hoax or misdirection, turning what sounds like a digital thriller into a wild goose chase, while the real clues might lie elsewhere.